Christmas Eve gift box (they get to open it on Christmas Eve)! They get new pjs (to wear that night), a Christmas movie, hot chocolate, snacks for the movie, etc. We already do pjs and slippers as our Christmas Eve gift but this is even better!
Magic Elf Seeds... delivered by our Elf on the Shelf
Magic Elf Seeds--Use tic tacs and sugar. The kids plant the 'seeds' before they go to bed and when they wake up they are candy canes! Elf on the Shelf could leave the seeds for the kids to plant that night.
Add a bell for every year starting with your first Christmas as a married couple. Add red bells for when you have a baby, and green bells when you have grand kids. Can use a Sharpie to write the year on the bell