December 14. If you want to you can comment " yes " or " no " because I know this is a popular debate in this fandom. Im not completely sure myself actually. It's hard because if Hollyleaf had told Firestar about Ashfur's plot than he could have decided on a punishment ( probably exile ) but because she now knows who her REAL parents are the is afraid to tell anycat. She seems not to have meant to fatally hurt Ashfur. ITS JUST SO CONFUSING ITS LIKE ASDFGHJKL!!!!